Scythe Ninja 3 - Conclusion

Written by Luke Ponio    Sunday, 25 July 2010 21:11
Article Index
Scythe Ninja 3
Packaging and Design
Fan
Installation
Testing Results
Conclusion
All Pages

I just want to preface the conclusion by saying that this review took the longest of any reviews I’ve ever done. The Intel Q9400 CPU that I was testing with seemed to get stuck at certain idle temperatures no matter the ambient or cooler being tested. In an effort to get better idle software temperatures I began testing on an AMD Phenom II platform, but three-quarters of the way through testing I ran into some system instability that I am still troubleshooting at the time of this posting (it has no relation to the Ninja 3). So I went back to the Intel system and decided I would just use my probe for idle temperatures. This worked great until the hard drive I was using died. I just thought I would share some notes on my tribulations doing this review to comfort myself after spending over 40 hours getting a good review finished. I know there are some people out there that can sympathize when computers just don’t want to cooperate.

Scythe Ninja 3

The main selling point of the Ninja 3 is definitely performance. Installation was a bit unrefined and I hope some improvement can be made in the next revision. Even seemingly small things like using longer screws would help stop frustration caused by mounting the heatsink. I know that this cooler is quite large and needs a sturdy mounting mechanism but I would also rather have the option of not having to remove the motherboard after initial installation of the back-plate. Some other heatsinks have a good method that secures the back-plate to the board so you can remove the cooler without removing the motherboard. This saves a lot of time if you are doing something simple like swapping CPUs.

Current price for the Ninja 3 at time of writing is $49.99 which is similar to other high-end CPU coolers. There is definitely value in the $49.99 price since the cooler includes a great fan and fan controller as well as a 2-year warranty.

I was really looking forward to testing this heatsink. The Ninja Plus rev. B that I have been using for years is one of my favorite heatsinks of all time. Scythe nailed the performance improvement but took a step back in installation method. If they can somehow make installation easier they will have a real contender for best heatsink in the market. If you have an older Ninja or are looking to upgrade to a high performance heatsink, the Scythe Ninja 3 is a great option worthy of your dollars.

 

InsaneTek Recommended

Pros:

  • Great performance
  • Quiet at low speed
  • Big improvement over old model
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Difficult installation
  • Fan controller is not removable

We would like to thank Scythe for providing us the sample.  If you have any questions or comments, feel free to hit us up in the forums. You can also check out more of our latest reviews and tech news on the front page.